A giant controversy has erupted in the world of Australian football! The EJ Whitten Medal, an iconic award for Victoria's best player, has been bestowed upon Lachie Ash, but our expert analysis reveals a different story. We've got four players who, according to our ratings, outshone Ash!
Get ready for a deep dive into the 2026 AFL Origin game, where we'll explore the performances that had us questioning the medal decision.
But here's where it gets controversial...
Toby Greene (GWS Giants): A true game-changer, Greene was a constant threat, scoring two goals and setting up plays with his 18 touches and 11 marks. His performance earned him an impressive rating of 8.
Jack Sinclair (St Kilda): Unfortunately, Sinclair's impact off half-back wasn't as dominant as we've come to expect. His rating of 4 reflects a quieter night for this usually stellar player.
Caleb Serong (Fremantle): Serong proved his worth on the big stage, especially in the first quarter with his nine disposals, three of which led to Victoria's scores. His crucial goal in the fourth term was the icing on the cake, earning him a well-deserved rating of 6.
Marcus Bontempelli (Western Bulldogs): As captain of a star-studded team, Bontempelli didn't shy away from the spotlight. He stepped up and delivered, finishing with 30 touches, half of which led to Victoria's scores. His ability to set up teammates was exceptional, and he earned an impressive rating of 8.
And this is the part most people miss...
Hugh McCluggage (Brisbane Lions): Starting on the wing, McCluggage also drifted forward, booting two goals in the first half. While he quietened down after halftime, his early impact was undeniable, earning him a rating of 7.
Zach Merrett (Essendon): Starting on the bench, Merrett made an immediate impact with nine disposals and a goal in the first quarter. Fox Footy's Jonathan Brown praised his return, especially after some off-season controversy. Merrett's solid performance throughout the game earned him a rating of 7.
Nick Daicos (Collingwood): Despite early jeers from the WA locals, Daicos thrived. His intercept and kick set up Bontempelli's first major, and he dominated the second quarter with his line-breaking and burst speed. When WA made a late challenge, Daicos was still the most prolific player, kicking one goal and earning an impressive rating of 8.
Zak Butters (Port Adelaide): As a free agent, Butters started the year with a bang. He was Victoria's spark, always involved in the action. His workrate across the field was exceptional, and he finished with 27 touches and seven inside 50s. Butters' performance will undoubtedly be a talking point, especially with the race for his signature heating up. He earned a well-deserved rating of 8.
So, who do you think deserved the EJ Whitten Medal? Join the discussion and let us know your thoughts! We want to hear from you!
