Venmo vs. Zelle: Which is Better? (2024)

A few months ago, I organized a gift (from 30 women) for a friend’s big birthday. So 
I sent an email with the amount owed and my address. Five minutes later, a woman emailed back: “Can I Venmo you?”

Could she? I’d never used the mobile-payment service, but my kids do.
 I downloaded the app, opened an account (in 
no time at all) and sent a second email: “Or, if you’d prefer, you can Venmo me.” I still received checks and cash, but most went the electronic route — and collecting from a large group was never easier.

Venmo is a cash-transferring system sometimes called a digital wallet; it’s owned by PayPal. According to research from Finder.com, 43 percent of Americans have used a digital wallet in the past year. And those numbers will likely grow with the recent launch of Zelle, from bank-owned Early Warning Services.

Are the systems safe? Generally, yes. Both use state-of-the-art tool s
and encryption to keep your data — and cash transfers — secure. The drawback? Consumers generally spend more money overall with digital wallets than they do with credit cards, debit cards or cash, says the Finder.com study.

Venmo vs. Zelle

The Platform

Venmo: Operates through the Venmo app you download to your mobile device.

Zelle: Operates through apps of participating banks and credit unions.

How it Works

Venmo: Transferring is easiest if both parties are
on the app. You can “request” or “pay” other users and add
 a note or emoji as the transaction description. You can also send money to family and friends in the U.S. using their cellphone number or email.

Zelle: Users who have accounts at a participating bank can send money to anyone for whom they have a cellphone number or email address. Recipients who don’t bank with Zelle partners can claim their money by signing up at clearxchange.com.

Venmo vs. Zelle: Which is Better? (2024)

FAQs

Which is safer to use Venmo or Zelle? ›

Some people prefer Zelle to Venmo; others love Venmo more. Both of the payment services are decently safe, have user-friendly interfaces, and allow you to conveniently send money when you need it.

What is the downside to Venmo? ›

Potential scams and hackers.

The biggest downside to using Venmo is the potential for your money to be stolen. If a hacker gains access to your Venmo, it's pretty easy to change the associated bank account – so the hacker could change the account to their own and transfer the money in your Venmo to their bank.

What can you not use Venmo for? ›

Can I use Venmo to sell goods or services? The only way to accept payments for goods and services on Venmo is to be explicitly authorized to accept Venmo for purchases. This can be achieved by applying for a business profile or by having the sender tag a payment to a personal profile as a purchase.

Does Zelle charge fees? ›

Zelle® doesn't charge a fee to send or receive money. We recommend confirming with your bank or credit union that there are no fees for Zelle® transactions. Was this helpful?

What is downside of using Zelle? ›

Unlike many money transfer apps, Zelle does not charge a fee for instant transfers. Zelle transfers are generally secure, but the app does carry risks, including the risk of glitches at banks that can affect money transfers.

Will Zelle refund money if scammed? ›

How to Get Your Money Back. Zelle is processing each scam claim they receive on a case-by-case basis. If you haven't already done so, file a claim directly with Zelle through their app or by phone (844-428-8542). You'll also need to file a claim with the bank or credit union your funds were taken.

Can someone get your bank info from Venmo? ›

The communication will include a link to a look-alike Venmo website where the scammers can capture your login information. From here, the scammers are able to steal your identity and use your account information to gain greater access to your bank account and your friends and family.

What's the difference between Zelle and Venmo? ›

Zelle is a gateway service which allows you to send and receive - but not hold - funds. Venmo has a wallet function, so you can hold a balance. If your bank allows Zelle payments, you can use it with your regular online banking app - Venmo users will need a separate app to make payments.

What are two pros and cons of Venmo? ›

Venmo pros and cons
ProsCons
Safe to use Fast and convenient Can sign up for a Venmo debit or credit card Can use at select businessesNot every transaction is free Can't cancel payments No international payments or requests

Will Venmo refund money if scammed? ›

Venmo has a Purchase Protection Program that offers some protection when buying or selling from a business account or a personal account that qualifies. But if you transfer money to a stranger or get scammed on Venmo, you most likely won't get refunded.

How do I get my money when someone pays me on Venmo? ›

Whenever you receive a payment on Venmo, that money is put into your Venmo account. You'll need to initiate a bank transfer to send the funds to your bank account. You can send the money in your Venmo account to your bank using the Standard or Instant method.

Does Venmo charge a fee? ›

Does Venmo have a transaction fee for instant transfers? Yes, the app charges 1.75% of the total amount for instant transaction services. In addition, standard electronic transfers of funds to your account are processed without fees.

Does Zelle report to IRS? ›

Zelle® does not report any transactions made on the Zelle Network® to the IRS, even if the total is more than $600. The law requiring certain payment networks to provide forms 1099K for information reporting does not apply to the Zelle Network®.

Is Zelle completely free? ›

Zelle® is free2 to use.

When you send money to friends or family, it won't cost you any extra money for the transaction. Which is good, because there are way better things to spend money on, like concert tickets… or vacations.

Do you need a bank account for Zelle? ›

Find out if your financial institution offers Zelle®. Important: While you can typically use Zelle® with people at different banks, at least one person must have a bank in the Zelle Network in order to send and receive money.

Why do people prefer Venmo over Zelle? ›

For those looking for a digital wallet that allows you to accrue and hold funds, Venmo might be the better option, as you cannot maintain a cash balance with Zelle. Additionally, payments sent through Zelle can't be canceled if the recipient is already enrolled with Zelle.

What is the most secure way to send money? ›

Venmo, Cash App, Google Pay, Zelle, PayPal, and wire transfer are some of the safest way to send money digitally. Money transfer apps are inexpensive and convenient options for paying family and friends. Wire transfers at a bank are ideal for securely sending large amounts domestically or internationally.

Will Venmo refund money if hacked? ›

Does Venmo have fraud protection? Venmo has a Purchase Protection Program that offers some protection when buying or selling from a business account or a personal account that qualifies. But if you transfer money to a stranger or get scammed on Venmo, you most likely won't get refunded.

What is the safest way to receive money from a stranger? ›

The safest way to receive money from a stranger online is to use secure and reputable payment methods that prioritize user protection. For instance, you can use a platform like PayPal to receive money from someone you haven't met before. You can also use cryptocurrency—it is a practical way.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6117

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Birthday: 1995-01-14

Address: 55021 Usha Garden, North Larisa, DE 19209

Phone: +6812240846623

Job: Corporate Healthcare Strategist

Hobby: Singing, Listening to music, Rafting, LARPing, Gardening, Quilting, Rappelling

Introduction: My name is Foster Heidenreich CPA, I am a delightful, quaint, glorious, quaint, faithful, enchanting, fine person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.